Back to the Future: IBM WorkPad z50 and Lenovo IdeaPad S10
To prevent the previous post in this series from becoming a one-off, one-hit wonder, I have been tirelessly searching the past two weeks for another Blast from the Past. The inspiration came to me when I saw that Lenovo began selling their IdeaPad S10 netbook earlier this week. Looking at the IBM WorkPad z50 lying next to my desk. I began to realize the similarities.
Even though the IdeaPad is much more of a full-fledged notebook than the WorkPad ever was, they occupy a very similar niche and have similar form factors. The WorkPad z50 for those unfamiliar was a Windows CE-based Handheld PC. It had a QWERTY keyboard and the trademark red eraserhead trackpoint from the ThinkPads. It was meant to be an ultraportable companion for a computer when portability was key and a true ultraportable notebook was too expensive or did not have enough battery life. In this regards, the IdeaPad S10 is the spiritual successor to the WorkPad z50. Fast forward 9 years, and true ultraportable laptops still cost an arm and a leg. Netbooks, like the IdeaPad, offer the portability of a small computer without the cost. They also have limitations, like the WorkPad, in that they cannot do everything a full-sized computer can.
The specifications of these two devices are actually quite similar considering they were released almost a decade apart. In fact, some of the numbers would even be closer if we were to consider the IdeaPad S9, but Lenovo has decided not to sell that model in the U.S.
WorkPad z50 vs. IdeaPad S10
| IBM WorkPad z50 | Lenovo IdeaPad S10 | |
|---|---|---|
| Screen | 8.4” VGA DSTN (passive matrix) | 10.2” WSVGA TFT (active matrix) |
| Processor | NEC VR4121 MIPS 131MHz | Intel Atom N270 1.6GHz |
| RAM | 16MB (for storage) | 512MB |
| Storage | 16MB ROM (for OS, programs) | 80GB hard drive |
| Expansion | CompactFlash, PC Card | ExpressCard |
| Weight | 2.66 lbs. | 2.4 lbs. |
| Operating System | Windows CE 2.11 | Windows XP Home |
| Price (when released) | $999 | $429 |
The IdeaPad uses a spinning hard drive, while many competing netbooks use solid state drives (SSDs), which would make the storage numbers even closer.
As I have said before, I own an IBM WorkPad z50. Unfortunately, the screen is cracked on it now, so I cannot carry it around with me to use it as something to take notes on or check my calendar. With a wireless card plugged in, I could even surf the internet and check email. Today, this role could be played by a netbook like the Lenovo IdeaPad S10. The new class of netbooks that are coming out allow me to do 75% of what I need an ultraportable laptop for at 25% the price. Some good, old ideas never die.
Similar Posts:
- Netbooks: Fad or Future?
- Are netbooks emasculating?
- Pipe Dream: Netbook Tablet PC
- Here comes another one: New Asus Eee PC 1000HE
- Rumor Mill: Dell Studio XPS 13












Better comparison: Lenovo IdeaPad s10 vs. ThinkPad 240 series (240 & 240x)
Recapping the stats on the IdeaPad:
10.2” WSVGA TFT (active matrix)
Intel Atom N270 1.6GHz
512MB RAM
80GB hard drive
1 ExpressCard Slot
2.4 lbs
Original loaded OS: Windows XP Home
Now the ThinkPad 240:
Intel Mobile Celeron 300, 366 or 400 CPU
Neomagic MagicGraph128XD with 2MB VRAM
10.4″ TFT display with 800×600 resolution
64MB PC-66 memory standard, (soft) max 192MB (I have 320 in mine!)
6.4 or 12GB HDD
IrDA 1.1
ES1946 (Solo) Audio controller
MiniPCI slot with a Lucent 1646 Modem
CardBus slot (Type 2)
2.8 to 3 pounds, depending on battery used.
Released in 2000.
Basically the ThinkPad 240 had the same niche upon its release as the Apple MacBook Air has now: a very expensive and light little computer meant to be a CEO toy. The 240 came with a floppy drive, and you had to get a 3rd party PCMCIA optical drive if you wanted an optical drive option.
However, NOW it feels like the true predecessor of the Netbook. Only this little Netbook has a REAL THINKPAD KEYBOARD and a Trackpoint pointing device, complete with little red “eraserhead” cap. Considering how crappy most Netbook keyboards and pointing devices are, it’s good to have a Genuine ThinkPad keyboard and Trackpoint.
My 240 is going to have a 16GB Transcend SLC-type SSD drive as soon as I get it from eBay. This should lighten it up, even with the high-capacity “hump” battery, and I should have ZERO netbook envy.
Leave your response!